- English name：
- Broadcast time：November 29, 2011
- Starring：黎明（Leon Lai Ming） 、张涵予（Zhang Hanyu） 、刘亦菲（Crystal Liu） 、冯绍峰（William） 、黄秋生（Anthony Wong） 、陈小春（Jordan Chan）、安志杰（Andy On）
- director：李仁港（Daniel Lee）
Introduction
Today,we are going to talk about a Hong Kong film, the director Daniel Lee (李仁港Lǐ Réngǎng) has caused somewhat of a stir as his new film “White Vengeance(鸿门宴hóngményàn) ” provides a different perspective on the Banquet of Hongmen, considered a key turning point in Chinese history.
The film starring Leon Lai (黎明Lí Míng), Feng Shaofeng (冯绍峰Féng Shàofēng), Zhang Hanyu (张涵予Zhāng Hányǔ) and Anthony Wong (黄秋生Huáng Qiūshēng) is set during the fall of the Qin Dynasty (221-206 BC), when sworn brothers Xiang Yu (项羽Xiàng Yǔ) and Liu Bang (刘邦Liú Bāng) both had ambitions of becoming the emperor.
Plot
It tells the story of how they turned against each other, and how Liu escapes a banquet where Xiang plots to assassinate him.
While Liu and Xiang’s battle of courage, patience and wits plays out, the film also delves into the fight between their counselors and warriors.
Lee, known for his martial arts films “Black Mask” and “14 Blades” does well at depicting the characters’ delicate and complicated emotional changes through aggressive action-packed confrontations.
During the Banquet at Hongmen, the two famous counselors Fan Zeng and Zhang Liang play the game of go (weiqi) on behalf of their soldiers. The philosophy of I Ching, or the Book of Changes, is mentioned in this scene, indicating that the dominant and the subdominant can be reversed suddenly; sometimes all one needs is to wait for the enemy to make a big mistake.
In the film, Xiang quickly loses the support of the people due to his arrogance, whereas Liu’s forces grow in strength after he abolishes some draconian laws and decrees.
In a climactic battle, Liu’s army besieges Xiang’s army in Gaixia.
The film depicts the banquet as a cruel turning point in Liu’s life as he starts to take a new path of manipulating people and gradually loses the ability to trust others, even his good friends. Many of Liu’s warlords are killed after the suspicious emperor founds the Han Dynasty (206 BC-AD 220).
It took Lee more than three years to prepare and make “White Vengeance.” He considers this story about loyalty, betrayal and lust for power his best and most satisfying as it was not a simple rehash of historic events.
He has said he wants to portray the unknown sacrifices people make in their pursuit of power.
Of course, the Banquet at Hongmen has inspired film and television adaptations in the past. Lu Chuan directed “The Last Supper” and Gao Xixi made the TV drama “Legend of Chu and Han” based on the events that occurred so long ago.
“White Vengeance” is expected to meet strong competition from “The Flowers of War” and “Flying Swords of Dragon Gate.”
Professional evaluation
1、Overall, “Legend of the Hongmen Feast” is at least the best commercial film by Li Rengang after “Star Moon Fairy Tale”. In terms of production, in addition to the computer special effects scenes, the martial arts scenes are edited in a tough way, with strong impact and strong visual effects.
2、The Hongmen Banquet became a turning point in the Chu-Han dispute, and also determined the success or failure of Liu and Xiang’s future. In fact, Li Rengang’s version of “The Legend of the Hongmen Banquet” is to re-examine that period of history from a modern perspective, find a point and an angle to magnify it for the audience to see, and get reflection and self-examination from it.
3、The overall structure of this film is well designed. It subverts all our imaginations about this murderous dinner thousands of years ago. It also explains in detail why the two people got into trouble and the subsequent confrontation between the two sides. After the climax of the film, the story tells the impact of the Hongmen Banquet decades later and the fate of the characters like black and white twins in a chess game. This makes the story really thick and full of twists and turns.
